Jenny Replacement — comparison
All 16 analysed boats in this folder. Money never enters the capability score — different units, and collapsing them would hide the one trade this page exists to show.
What if the costs were different?
Scale a whole category and watch the boats move. It sounds like it should leave the order alone — it does not, because the boats carry very different mixes of hull work and gear. Nothing here is saved. Reloading the page undoes it.
What this hull needs for its own condition. Moves with the survey.
The standard fit-out, identical on every boat. Moves with your choices.
Paid whether or not you buy her.
1The trade-off
What does capability cost, and does adjusting the budget change the answer?
Green ring and dashed line — the frontier: nothing on this list is both cheaper and better. Anything below and right of it is beaten outright by something here.
2Every dimension at once
Where does each boat win, where does it give something up, and which pairs actually cross?
What these 6 axes will mislead you about
- All-in cash
- Everything needed to reach the start line: purchase, refit, tax, holding, reserve. This is the number to compare boats on.
- A central estimate. The worst case is a separate dimension for a reason.
- Capability (weighted)judged, not measured
- The seven behaviour scores under the active weighting scheme. Money is deliberately absent — different units, and collapsing them would hide the one trade this page exists to show.
- Changes with the scheme. If a ranking only survives one weighting, it is not a ranking.
- Capsize screening
- Beam ÷ ∛(displacement ÷ 64). The Cruising Club of America built it from the 1979 Fastnet fleet: under 2.0 was judged acceptable for offshore racing. Lower is better.
- The CCA calls its own formula rough and the 2.0 line is an arbitrary cutoff, not a result. It sees only beam and weight — it is blind to hull shape and to where the ballast sits, so a light hull with a deep bulb and a heavy hull with a shallow full keel can score identically and behave nothing alike. Published figures are dry; a loaded cruising boat screens better than its spec sheet.
- Motion comfort
- Ted Brewer's ratio: displacement over a heel-adjusted waterplane area. High means a slow, heavy motion; low means a quick one. Brewer put successful moderate ocean cruisers in the low-to-mid 30s.
- Brewer devised it half in jest and it is the weakest number here. It describes pitching into head seas and nothing else — it says nothing about roll, which is what actually punishes you on a downwind trade-wind route, and beamy flat hulls that score badly often roll less. It does not correlate with safety or offshore capability despite being constantly presented as if it does.
- Water, two up
- Tankage ÷ two people × 5 US gal a head a day. The longest milk-run leg is around three weeks, so this is the dimension that decides whether a watermaker is optional or required.
- Five gallons a head assumes salt-water washing and a fresh rinse. It is an assumption, not a measurement, and a watermaker makes the whole axis moot.
- How much is known
- Share of systems somebody has actually assessed. Drives the unknown reserve, and it is the one dimension you can move by spending a Saturday rather than money.
3The design numbers, against the conventional ranges
Forget the other boats — is this hull suitable at all?
Every other chart here is relative and will happily give you a first place out of five unsuitable boats. This one is absolute: it puts each figure against the ranges the trade actually uses. The zones are rules of thumb and the printed value is what says how near an edge a boat sits.
Capsize screening
lower is better
- Oyster 53 BELLAMARE1.66Comfortable offshore margin
- Wally WALLY WALLY LOVE1.75Comfortable offshore margin
- Beneteau First 36.7 Bella Vita1.93Passes the CCA screen
- Beneteau First 36.71.93Passes the CCA screen
- Beneteau First 36.7 Allegro1.94Passes the CCA screen
- Jeanneau Sun Fast 351.99Passes the CCA screen
- Catalina 36 MkII EMESE2.00Marginal — may pass loaded
- Beneteau 3312.03Marginal — may pass loaded
- Beneteau First 10R Salient2.04Marginal — may pass loaded
- Catalina 34 Easy Thing2.06Marginal — may pass loaded
- Bavaria 36 Capella2.06Marginal — may pass loaded
- Beneteau Oceanis 342.06Marginal — may pass loaded
- X-Yachts X-362 Sport Nora2.07Marginal — may pass loaded
- Beneteau Oceanis 321 Let It Be2.10Marginal — may pass loaded
- Wally 107 SPIRIT OF MALOUEN X2.13Marginal — may pass loaded
- Dufour 342.17Marginal — may pass loaded
The CCA calls its own formula rough and the 2.0 line is an arbitrary cutoff, not a result. It sees only beam and weight — it is blind to hull shape and to where the ballast sits, so a light hull with a deep bulb and a heavy hull with a shallow full keel can score identically and behave nothing alike. Published figures are dry; a loaded cruising boat screens better than its spec sheet.
Motion comfort
higher is better
- Dufour 3419.1Quick, lively motion
- Beneteau Oceanis 321 Let It Be19.7Quick, lively motion
- Wally 107 SPIRIT OF MALOUEN X19.9Quick, lively motion
- X-Yachts X-362 Sport Nora20.5Coastal cruiser
- Bavaria 36 Capella21.3Coastal cruiser
- Beneteau First 10R Salient21.3Coastal cruiser
- Beneteau 33121.6Coastal cruiser
- Catalina 34 Easy Thing22.2Coastal cruiser
- Jeanneau Sun Fast 3522.3Coastal cruiser
- Beneteau Oceanis 3422.4Coastal cruiser
- Catalina 36 MkII EMESE24.0Coastal cruiser
- Beneteau First 36.7 Allegro24.2Coastal cruiser
- Beneteau First 36.7 Bella Vita24.7Coastal cruiser
- Beneteau First 36.724.7Coastal cruiser
- Wally WALLY WALLY LOVE35.9Moderate ocean cruiser
- Oyster 53 BELLAMARE42.7Heavy, slow motion
Brewer devised it half in jest and it is the weakest number here. It describes pitching into head seas and nothing else — it says nothing about roll, which is what actually punishes you on a downwind trade-wind route, and beamy flat hulls that score badly often roll less. It does not correlate with safety or offshore capability despite being constantly presented as if it does.
Sail area / displacement
a target range, not a direction
- Oyster 53 BELLAMARE14.2Cruiser
- Beneteau 33115.7Cruiser
- Catalina 36 MkII EMESE15.7Cruiser
- Catalina 34 Easy Thing16.0Cruiser
- Beneteau Oceanis 3416.0Cruiser
- Bavaria 36 Capella16.7Cruiser
- Jeanneau Sun Fast 3517.5Performance cruiser
- Beneteau Oceanis 321 Let It Be17.7Performance cruiser
- Dufour 3418.7Performance cruiser
- Beneteau First 36.7 Bella Vita19.1Performance cruiser
- Beneteau First 36.7 Allegro19.2Performance cruiser
- Beneteau First 36.719.3Performance cruiser
- Beneteau First 10R Salient19.4Performance cruiser
- X-Yachts X-362 Sport Nora21.0Racer — overpowered cruising
- Wally 107 SPIRIT OF MALOUEN X55.9Racer — overpowered cruising
- Wally WALLY WALLY LOVE — not published
Only comparable when computed the same way. These figures use 100% foretriangle plus mainsail; a brochure quoting an overlapping genoa reads 10–15% higher for the same boat. More sail is not better for two people — it is more to handle.
Displacement / length
a target range, not a direction
- Wally 107 SPIRIT OF MALOUEN X41Ultralight
- Wally WALLY WALLY LOVE89Ultralight
- Jeanneau Sun Fast 35167Light
- X-Yachts X-362 Sport Nora171Light
- Beneteau Oceanis 321 Let It Be171Light
- Dufour 34173Light
- Beneteau 331176Light
- Bavaria 36 Capella185Light
- Beneteau First 10R Salient194Light
- Beneteau Oceanis 34194Light
- Catalina 34 Easy Thing201Moderate
- Beneteau First 36.7 Allegro206Moderate
- Beneteau First 36.7 Bella Vita209Moderate
- Beneteau First 36.7209Moderate
- Catalina 36 MkII EMESE218Moderate
- Oyster 53 BELLAMARE242Moderate
Sensitive to which displacement is quoted. Light-ship versus half-load can move this 20%, and a cruising boat leaves the dock nearer the second.
Ballast ratio
higher is better
- Beneteau Oceanis 3425%Tender
- Jeanneau Sun Fast 3526%Tender
- Bavaria 36 Capella27%Tender
- Oyster 53 BELLAMARE28%Tender
- Beneteau 33129%Tender
- Beneteau First 36.7 Allegro29%Tender
- Beneteau First 36.7 Bella Vita30%Tender
- Beneteau First 36.731%Typical cruiser
- Beneteau Oceanis 321 Let It Be31%Typical cruiser
- Dufour 3432%Typical cruiser
- Beneteau First 10R Salient36%Typical cruiser
- Wally 107 SPIRIT OF MALOUEN X40%Stiff
- X-Yachts X-362 Sport Nora41%Stiff
- Catalina 34 Easy Thing42%Stiff
- Catalina 36 MkII EMESE44%Stiff
- Wally WALLY WALLY LOVE — not published
A share, not a lever arm. 40% in a shoal keel two feet down does less than 30% in a bulb six feet down, and this number cannot tell them apart. Read it beside draft and keel type, never alone.
Angle of vanishing stability
Not published for any boat on this list. Common for this figure — it is not a sign that anything is wrong with them.
4Head to head
Two boats, and only the dimensions on which they genuinely differ.
Catalina 34 Easy Thing is better on
- Ballast ratio42% vs 29%
- Open questions20 vs 24
- Displacement / length201 vs 176
- Speed and rangejudged5.3/10 vs 3.8/10
- Passage reliabilityjudged5.0/10 vs 4.0/10
- Water, two up7 days vs 5 days
- Capability (weighted)judged5.24/10 vs 4.96/10
Beneteau 331 is better on
- Waterline / overall90% vs 86%
- Shorthanded handlingjudged8.0/10 vs 7.0/10
- Refit$44k vs $60k
Gates, money flow, uncertainty and rank stability
The six charts from the methodology review: who clears the gates and by what margin, what each boat’s bill is made of, which numbers are still soft and what one diligence action would firm up, and whether the ranking survives a change of weighting.
Weighting scheme
- Suits:
- Two people on a well-understood downwind route in season, living aboard for eight or nine months, wanting the boat easy on them every single day. The 3 a.m. squall-line sail change is the modal emergency of this route, and it is a shorthandedHandling event, not a stormSafety event.
- Sacrifices:
- Ultimate-storm margin beyond the gate floor, and any pretence that heavy-weather capability is the main axis of this trip. Storm exposure is handled twice already: once by the stability gate, once by its 10 points.
- Favours:
- Moderate-displacement production boats with good deck layouts and modern systems — the Beneteaus, the Catalina; tolerates in-mast furling. The heavy trio stays live via reliability and comfort but loses ground on speedAndRange per dollar. The catamaran scores brilliantly here if it survives the budget gate — exactly why money must stay a separate axis.
1Efficient frontier — what capability costs
Capability under Milk-Run Default against the cash required to reach the start line. Greyed boats are dominated: something else is both cheaper and better.
On the frontier
- Catalina 34 Easy Thing$98k · 5.14
- Beneteau First 36.7 Allegro$111k · 5.28
- Catalina 36 MkII EMESE$129k · 5.80
- Oyster 53 BELLAMARE$567k · 7.78
Dominated — cheaper and better exists
- Beneteau Oceanis 321 Let It Be$107k · 5.05 · beaten by 1
- Beneteau 331$111k · 4.91 · beaten by 2
- Beneteau First 36.7 Bella Vita$122k · 4.91 · beaten by 3
- Jeanneau Sun Fast 35$130k · 5.44 · beaten by 1
- Bavaria 36 Capella$137k · 5.11 · beaten by 4
- Beneteau First 10R Salient$150k · 4.63 · beaten by 8
- Dufour 34$153k · 5.33 · beaten by 2
- X-Yachts X-362 Sport Nora$162k · 5.16 · beaten by 4
- Beneteau Oceanis 34$165k · 5.33 · beaten by 2
- Beneteau First 36.7$177k · 4.92 · beaten by 9
- Wally WALLY WALLY LOVE$5.2m · 6.21 · beaten by 1
- Wally 107 SPIRIT OF MALOUEN X$6.0m · 4.64 · beaten by 14
Reads wrong if: The y-axis is a weighted opinion, not a measurement. A 0.3 gap is noise; a 1.5 gap is real. And the catamaran's distance to the right is the finding, not a scaling problem — do not read the axis as broken.
2Gate board — who is actually in the fleet
Hard constraints, run before any scoring. Margins are printed rather than ticks, because a week of schedule slack and six months are not the same answer.
| Boat | Stability | Schedule | Peak cash | Insurable |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Catalina 34 Easy Thing | CSF 2.06 — over 2.0, AVS needed | ready in 8wk — 0wk spare | $78k vs $200k | quote needed before offer |
| Beneteau 331 | CSF 2.03 — over 2.0, AVS needed | ready in 8wk — 0wk spare | $91k vs $200k | quote needed before offer |
| Beneteau First 36.7 Allegro | CSF 1.94 — under 2.0, no AVS | ready in 8wk — 0wk spare | $100k vs $200k | quote needed before offer |
| Beneteau Oceanis 321 Let It Be | CSF 2.1 — over 2.0, AVS needed | ready in 8wk — 0wk spare | $89k vs $200k | quote needed before offer |
| Beneteau First 36.7 Bella Vita | CSF 1.93 — under 2.0, no AVS | ready in 8wk — 0wk spare | $100k vs $200k | quote needed before offer |
| Catalina 36 MkII EMESE | CSF 2 — over 2.0, AVS needed | ready in 8wk — 0wk spare | $103k vs $200k | quote needed before offer |
| Jeanneau Sun Fast 35 | CSF 1.99 — under 2.0, no AVS | ready in 8wk — 0wk spare | $105k vs $200k | quote needed before offer |
| Bavaria 36 Capella | CSF 2.06 — over 2.0, AVS needed | ready in 8wk — 0wk spare | $100k vs $200k | quote needed before offer |
| Beneteau First 10R Salient | CSF 2.04 — over 2.0, AVS needed | ready in 8wk — 0wk spare | $125k vs $200k | quote needed before offer |
| Dufour 34 | CSF 2.17 — over 2.0, AVS needed | ready in 9wk — 0wk spare | $132k vs $200k | quote needed before offer |
| X-Yachts X-362 Sport Nora | CSF 2.07 — over 2.0, AVS needed | ready in 8wk — 0wk spare | $134k vs $200k | quote needed before offer |
| Beneteau Oceanis 34 | CSF 2.06 — over 2.0, AVS needed | ready in 8wk — 0wk spare | $139k vs $200k | quote needed before offer |
| Beneteau First 36.7 | CSF 1.93 — under 2.0, no AVS | ready in 10wk — 0wk spare | $147k vs $200k | quote needed before offer |
| Oyster 53 BELLAMARE | CSF 1.66 — under 2.0, no AVS | ready in 8wk — 0wk spare | $481k vs $200k | quote needed before offer |
| Wally WALLY WALLY LOVE | CSF 1.75 — under 2.0, no AVS | ready in 8wk — 0wk spare | $4509k vs $200k | quote needed before offer |
| Wally 107 SPIRIT OF MALOUEN X | CSF 2.13 — over 2.0, AVS needed | ready in 15wk — 0wk spare | $5310k vs $200k | quote needed before offer |
Reads wrong if: Every stability cell is a fallback: no AVS was published for any of these hulls, so a green cell means 'capsize screening under 2.0', which is a coarse screen and not a measurement.
3Where the money goes
What each boat is actually made of. Explains the frontier's cost axis.
- Purchase
- Refit
- Holding
- refit worst case
Reads wrong if: Outflow only. This says nothing about what the boat is worth afterwards, and the refit half is an estimate with a tail — the darker block is the worst case on top of the likely one.
4Behaviour strip — balanced or spiky
Where each boat carries its weaknesses. A grid rather than a radar: radar charts make area look meaningful when the axes have no common unit, and reward whichever order you happened to put them in.
| Boat | Comfort at sea | At anchor | Durability | Speed | Storm | Two-handed | Parts |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Catalina 34 Easy Thing | 3 | 6 | 5 | 5.3 | 3 | 7 | 6 |
| Beneteau 331 | 3 | 6 | 4 | 3.8 | 3 | 8 | 6 |
| Beneteau First 36.7 Allegro | 5 | 5 | 5 | 5.5 | 4 | 6 | 7 |
| Beneteau Oceanis 321 Let It Be | 3 | 6 | 5 | 4 | 3 | 7 | 8 |
| Beneteau First 36.7 Bella Vita | 4 | 5 | 5 | 5.8 | 4 | 5 | 6 |
| Catalina 36 MkII EMESE | 4 | 7 | 6 | 5 | 4 | 7 | 8 |
| Jeanneau Sun Fast 35 | 4 | 5 | 5 | 6.3 | 4 | 7 | 7 |
| Bavaria 36 Capella | 3 | 6 | 5 | 4.8 | 3 | 7 | 7 |
| Beneteau First 10R Salient | 3 | 4 | 4 | 5.5 | 4 | 6 | 7 |
| Dufour 34 | 3 | 6 | 5 | 5.5 | 3 | 8 | 5 |
| X-Yachts X-362 Sport Nora | 3 | 5 | 6 | 5.8 | 4 | 6 | 6 |
| Beneteau Oceanis 34 | 3 | 6 | 5 | 4.5 | 3 | 8 | 8 |
| Beneteau First 36.7 | 4 | 5 | 5 | 5.5 | 4 | 5 | 7 |
| Oyster 53 BELLAMARE | 9 | 8 | 8 | 7.5 | 9 | 6 | 8 |
| Wally WALLY WALLY LOVE | 6 | 9 | 6 | 8.8 | 6 | 3 | 5 |
| Wally 107 SPIRIT OF MALOUEN X | 5 | 3 | 5 | 9.3 | 5 | 2 | 3 |
Reads wrong if: Scores describe the design after the refit is spent, not the boat as it sits. And the catamaran's storm-safety score covers a different failure mode — high initial stability, no self-righting.
5Uncertainty ladder — which numbers are still soft
Ranks your next diligence actions, not the boats. A wide bar and a pale fill mean the figure could move a long way and nobody has looked.
Reads wrong if: A narrow bar can mean a well-researched boat or a lazily-researched one. Read it with the assessed percentage, not on its own.
6Rank stability — does the weighting actually matter?
Each boat's rank under all four schemes. Flat lines mean the answer survives the values debate; crossings show exactly which boats the choice decides.
Reads wrong if: Stability across schemes is not correctness. All four schemes share the same seven dimensions and the same underlying scores, so they agree partly by construction.
Why the default scheme
Milk-Run Default — the route argues for it: overwhelmingly downwind trade-wind sailing in season on the most-travelled cruising highway on earth, with the one realistic storm exposure handled twice (stability gate + 10 points). What the route taxes daily, for ~60–70 sea days, is two people's ability to handle, fix, and rest on the boat: that is where the weight sits. Honest test: run Milk-Run Default and Storm Clause side by side in the rank-stability chart — if the same boats top both, the values argument is moot and you can stop having it.
What this comparison will mislead you about (6)
- The behaviour scores are the softest layer and about to become the most visible one: 1–10s assigned from listings, forums and reviews, sources biased toward owner enthusiasm. Defences: write a one-line observable-anchored rubric per dimension BEFORE scoring; score post-refit; mark evidence quality per cell and show the dots on the strip chart. Without rubrics the apparatus becomes a rationalisation engine with JSON output.
- The gates as stated will misfire if run as stated: CSF < 2.0 on published dry displacement fails four production boats (2.01–2.11) while five of ten monohulls sit within 0.06 of the line — inside the noise of the displacement figure. Run stability as a hierarchy (AVS where measured, CE category + design assessment, CSF-loaded as coarse screen) and print margins. Same disease on draft: two boats at exactly 6.50, one at 6.56-by-spec vs 6.5-by-listing. Gates must run on measured values or they manufacture pass/fail theatre at ±1 inch.
- The brief says ten boats; the project holds models for eleven. The Jeanneau reads like a boat half-dropped at the draft gate. Decide its status explicitly — a method whose denominator is fuzzy is not yet a method.
- diySaving is a currency exchange, not a discount: it converts money risk into schedule risk against the one deadline with no whisker. The never-DIY list (rigging, seacocks, LPG, saildrive diaphragms) is insurer-constrained; the one large prize (Noctiluca's deck, ~180–200 h ≈ $11k) would spend half a year of DIY budget on the fleet's second-riskiest boat. Ghost dots on the frontier: visible, never banked.
- weeksToReady gates the wrong end of the calendar: the binding constraint is arrival in Brisbane before ~November 2028 cyclone onset, and boat speed changes how much of the fixed season each boat consumes. Add arrivalMargin per boat and gate on both ends.
- Within-cluster comparisons are diligence contests, not weighting contests: Ki and Noctiluca tie on design by construction and differ by $18k of risk expectation — the price of a thin listing. Do not expect the schemes to separate boats inside a cluster; that is the uncertainty ladder's job.
Measures deliberately dropped (7)
Each of these was considered and cut, mostly for not discriminating between these ten boats or for double-counting something already measured. Adding them back would add noise, not information.
- askingPrice (as a comparator) — Most visible number, least meaningful: ask ordering and all-in ordering are nearly uncorrelated in this fleet (Mayari $69.5k ask carries ~$69k central required work; Affinity $130k carries $34.9k). Keep only for offer strategy.
- offerWithinBudget — A property of the wallet, not the boat. Constraint input to the budget gate, never a comparison output.
- SA/D — Spread across the monohulls is ~14.1–15.4 — a rounding error. It answered 'is any of these a racer or a caravan' and the answer is no. Retire to the anchor table.
- CE design category (as a compared measure) — Category A or equivalent fleet-wide; zero discrimination. Gate input only.
- motoringSpeed — Merged with motoringCapacity and speedLoaded into speedAndRange: expected loaded passage speed + range under power in nm. The tank spread (≈35 vs 130 gal ≈ 250 vs 900 nm) survives inside the merged score's rubric.
- motoringCapacity — Merged into speedAndRange (see motoringSpeed).
- payloadTolerance — Same idea as speedLoaded measured at a different load. Fix: define speedAndRange in full cruising trim (~a tonne for two crossing an ocean) and keep displacement-to-payload as an anchor input, not a dimension.